We’ve got a new computer at home for my wife. She declared that she wanted a Windows machine - “not one of those complicated Macs”, quote. She wanted a laptop, but isn’t likely to use it outside the home, so I bought a Fujitsu Siemens Amilo something or other, with a 15.4″ screen, Dual Core Pentium 1.6GHz, WiFi, 1Gb and a large enough disk. - it turned up in time for her birthday from JohnLewis.com and comes with a two year guarantee for a miserly £499.
This machine has Windows Vista Home Basic on it. I like the idea of Basic as there’s probably less junk to deinstall before it becomes usable. I happened to have seen a road-side Apple ad claiming that Macs work right out the box while PCs “can be a little complex to set up”. Having set up two Macbooks last year I was looking forward to the comparison.
The packaging was not nearly as sexy as the Macbook, but it was functional. Very strange photo on the packaging, will take a picture and post it here. The computer had a lot more bags and protective stuff on it than the Mac had, so there’s some reduction in materials possible there.
Once out, it’s an attactive enough, functional metal and grey box. Open it up, huge screen and small keyboard. Only complaint on the keyboard was that there HOME key is to the right of the DEL key, so guess what I kept pressing!
Plug in network and power, and off it goes. Starting the Mac gives a rather over the top theatrical experience with graphics and music. Vista’s installation was much more restrained. Vista asked me fewer questions than the OSX startup, and it didn’t try and cross sell me any services, unlike the .mac sign up.
The most noticable feature of the Vista setup was that, unlike the Mac, the various restarts, formats, etc were brutaly exposed, often leaving the user with a completely blank screen and a worrying feeling it’s all gone wrong. The Mac filled those times with flashy graphics.
Once up and running, the user management and login process are almost indistinguishable between Vista and OSX. Once logged in, the experience is basically like XP with round edges, with a few exceptions. The control panel mechanism seems to have been changed slightly, which means that you have to open your eyes while doing sys admin. Probably not a bad thing. The Basic rule had worked - the only thing needing deinstalling was Norton Decelerator, which was duely removed and replaced with AVG.
So what about Vista? First impression is that it is very fast. The Macbook with an identical processor felt sluggish in comparison. Internet connectivity could be taken from granted - it just happened - and I was downloading and installing things like Skype very, very easily. The installers are soooo much easier than those wierdo virtual disk things that OSX uses.
Of the two strange things I noticed, the first was that when you try and run anything that needs the slightest bit privileged access, or a downloaded application that hasn’t been used before, it blanks the screen for a moment to get your attention and then asks if it is ok to continue. It’s very annoying when setting up a new machine, but I can see the utility of it.
The second is that Windows Update installed a new “High Definition Audio Driver” on the first round of updates, and now the machine complains of “Wrong driver” when you log in. Can’t find any way of rolling back the driver, and only found one other person on the web with the same problem - and no solution.
This new computer was replacing my elder daughter’s elderly Vaio, which had suffered like most teenage-owned computers - tons of random junk installing itself. I’ve met several non-technical people complaining of this problem and wringing their hands as they didn’t know what to do. This new solution will ensure that doesn’t happen.
The new user interface is fine, nothing remarkable, really, and it comes with the mandatory widgets. Rather more elegant than the Mac ones, especially since these only start up when they have acquired all their data and are fully rendered. I particularly like the photo album widget. The Windows Explorer window comes up with the file tree on all the time, of which I fully approve. And on previous versions of Windows I had to go round changing the defaults on the Explorer - on Vista they were just right.
The only downsides, so far, have both been on the hardware. It’s claiming to have 750Mb, not 1Gb, despite reseating the memory. Sigh. Looks like a hardware fault. The other one drove me to read the manual - turning on the WiFi. Vista calmly told me that it couldn’t configure WiFi as it was turned off. But it couldn’t tell me how to turn it on. I had to read the manual - Fn-F2 to enable/disable WiFi. Once done it was a dawdle to set up, although the WEP/WPA/Who Knows options for security baffle me each time I use them, let alone an ordinary consumer.
One thing I did notice on Vista that perturbed me, but not for technical reasons. Shutdown has now been hidden off a submenu, driving users to put their machines in Standby. Can’t help feeling that promoting proper switch off would be more ecologically sound!
Conclusion: Vista initial use could be a little smoother, more cinematic, but otherwise it seems to be a very fast and friendly new version. The driver issue is a bit vexatious, however, and that needs looking at.